« In which Norm Feuti and I preach to the choir | Main | The Precedential Campaign »

10/16/2012

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Rich Powell

Bravo!

Sherwood Harrington

You know that if you ever do that thing in the penultimate paragraph again I'll heckle you for it, right?

But I sure liked it this time around.

Brian Fies

Criticism is a topic near to my heart. Good analysis and criticism is interesting and worthwhile, even if it comes from obscure bloggers who read 120+ strips per day (ahem). The all-purpose wounded response to critics, "You couldn't do any better," carries no weight with me. If a critic had to paint better than Rembrandt to have an opinion on Rembrandt (or be in the military to opine on military policy or be a woman to opine on women's issues, but those are peeves for another day), hardly anyone could criticize anything.

I'm not disagreeing with you--in fact I agree 97%--just looking at different facets. Martin's comeback to the heckler is funny, but sometimes someone telling you you suck is accurate and valuable feedback that does you a service.

I read the same blog post you did, thought it was a fair if inelegant analysis (especially damning to me were the examples of the cartoonist reusing the same gags within a few months), and never would have written anything like it myself. First, I've been on the receiving end, which, like a hanging in a fortnight, concentrates the mind wonderfully.

Second, I once lipped off on Usenet about a comic strip I thought was laughably lame and promptly got a note from the cartoonist himself warmly thanking me for my interest. That taught me a few things simultaneously: you never know who's reading; my opinion of the strip wasn't particularly strong or well thought out; when I really studied the strip, it was actually quite a good example of the type of feature it was intended to be; I was embarrassed; and the cartoonist was a very classy guy for pretending I hadn't insulted him. We've had a nice relationship since.

I also know my judgment is suspect, or at least not always a good barometer. There are critical darlings in the comics field whose work I don't grok or actively dislike. There are comics in the paper that, were I King of the Syndicates, would've never seen print, including some of the most successful. One story I don't mind telling because it's entirely on me is that I was at the New York ComicCon the day Jeff Kinney handed my editor his proposal for "Diary of a Wimpy Kid." I was the second person to read it, and I didn't get it. My editor did. And he was right and I was wrong and that's why Jeff's sold 70 million books and I haven't.

In the end, my policy is one of the most ancient and reliable: If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all. It's easy to sit on the sidelines picking and sniping; in my Book O' Life anyone who takes the risk of creating anything, even badly, is worth a hundred of them (ref. Teddy Roosevelt's "Man in the Arena").

The comments to this entry are closed.

What's so funny?

  • I read some 175 or more comics a day. Each day, I post a strip or two here that made me laugh, made me think or impressed me with its artistry. It's my hope that you'll see some new strips here and decide to follow that artist's work, and perhaps even to support that work by purchasing a collection of strips. But, mostly, I hope you'll find this a place to get a laugh or share a thought each day. After all, comic strips are a very demanding art form, but the ultimate point of all that work and all those deadlines is to give readers a little pleasure each day. If you find a comic hard to read, clicking on it will open a slightly larger version. (You may find that right-clicking and opening in a new tab produces a better result.) All comics here are copyrighted by their creators. -- Mike Peterson

The Prime Directive

  • The Prime Directive is that we don't single out comics for snark and abuse. This may change once I've won a couple of Pulitzers and a Reuben or two.

Twitteronomy

  • Want a daily reminder and link? My Twitter handle is @ComicStripOTD and I promise that you will never hear about what I had for lunch or the cute thing the dog said.

Independent publishers

  • Independent comic collections
    Not all cartoonists market their collections through Amazon. Here's where cartoonists can list their independently published, and marketed, collections and where fans can find, and buy, them.

Blog Roll

  • Comics Worth Reading
    Independent Opinions by Johanna Draper Carlson and friends News and reviews of graphic novels, manga, comic books, and related subjects
  • Comic Riffs
    Michael Cavna's Washington Post column on comics and related media news.
  • Mike Lynch Cartoons
    Cartoonist Mike Lynch's blog: Fascinating archival stuff he's found and scanned, tips on how cartooning really works and progress reports on his garden (in season).
  • The Comics Reporter
    Tom Spurgeon's Web site of comics news, reviews, interviews and commentary
  • Cartoon Movement
    An international site with sociopolitical cartoons from around the world, curated by Dutch cartoonist Tjeerd Royaards. A real mix of impressionistic panels and short-form graphic journalism.
  • Africartoons
    Cartoons from across Africa, which has an extremely lively cartooning culture. Most of the material requires you to be on top of African current events and political personalities, but even when you're not sure of the specifics, there's some creative stuff to envy in the lively nature of the art form as practiced there.

GoComics.com

  • GoComics.com
    Universal Press Syndicate's page. You can click on each strip and read for free, but for $11.88 a year, you can create your own page of strips and also avoid pop-ups. It's worth it.

Comics Kingdom

  • Comics Kingdom
    King Features' site, with free comics if you don't mind a truncated service, or a very good paid site for $20 a year. Some of the benefits, including Vintage strips, require that paid subscription. It's worth it.